Who Are the Top Best NFL Underdogs That Shocked Everyone?

Photo by Myron Mott on Unsplash

The NFL is full of stories about stars and superteams. But the league is also about underdogs — players and teams no one expected to succeed. They fight, survive, and sometimes dominate. Their moments inspire fans and remind us why football is unpredictable. Here are the top best NFL underdogs who shocked everyone.

1. 2007 New York Giants

Few believed the Giants could stop the undefeated Patriots. They did, in Super Bowl XLII, with David Tyree’s “helmet catch” sealing the upset.

2. Kurt Warner — St. Louis Rams

Warner went from stocking shelves at a grocery store to NFL MVP. He led the Rams to a Super Bowl and became one of football’s biggest surprises.

3. 2010 Green Bay Packers

Picked by many to falter after a slow start, the Packers came alive in the playoffs and won Super Bowl XLV behind Aaron Rodgers.

4. Nick Foles — Philadelphia Eagles

Foles took over midseason and led the Eagles to a Super Bowl win in 2018. His “Philly Special” is one of the greatest trick plays ever.

5. 1999 St. Louis Rams

Nobody expected the Rams to dominate with Kurt Warner and Marshall Faulk. They went from obscurity to winning the Super Bowl in style.

6. 2001 New England Patriots

Tom Brady was a second-year quarterback. The Patriots were 6th seed underdogs and went on to win Super Bowl XXXVI.

7. Doug Williams — Washington Redskins

Williams became the first Black quarterback to win a Super Bowl in 1988. His poise and play shocked everyone.

8. 1980 Oakland Raiders

The Raiders had many doubters, but Jim Plunkett led them to a Super Bowl victory as a backup QB.

9. Tony Romo — Dallas Cowboys

Often doubted, Romo carried the Cowboys to multiple playoff appearances, proving critics wrong with clutch performances.

10. 2013 Seattle Seahawks

Seattle was strong, but few expected their defense to dominate the Broncos 43–8 in Super Bowl XLVIII. The Legion of Boom shocked the world.

11. Doug Flutie — Buffalo Bills

Flutie, undrafted and overlooked, came in to lead the Bills and became a fan favorite, earning Rookie of the Year honors in his unique journey.

12. 1997 Denver Broncos

John Elway had been doubted after past Super Bowl losses. He led Denver to back-to-back championships, silencing critics.

13. 1985 New England Patriots

The Patriots made it to Super Bowl XX as a wild card. They lost, but their playoff run as underdogs amazed fans.

14. 2015 Carolina Panthers

Cam Newton and the Panthers were underestimated. They finished 15–1 and dominated NFC competition, even if they lost the Super Bowl.

15. 1992 Buffalo Bills

The Bills faced doubt in every Super Bowl, but their four consecutive appearances proved their resilience and ability to shock opponents.

“Note: This Article may contain affiliate links to support my work and recommendations.”

Comments